Sunday, September 28, 2008

The ethics of disability disclosure

A disability related question to The Ethicist in The NY Times Sept. 28. The ethicist has the correct answer but it is upsetting that models would behave in such a discriminatory way.


I have a fledgling photography business, mostly shooting aspiring models. I am a full-time wheelchair user. When I mention that in e-mail messages when booking a shoot, I get a lot of cancellations — a model suddenly remembers a prior engagement — or just out-and-out no-shows. Is it ethical not to say up front that I have a disability? — JACK HENIFORD, YORK, S.C.

You have the same ethical duty to alert people that you are a wheelchair user that you have to warn them that you are African-American or gay or a fan of lite jazz: none. (Well, maybe this last, if you intend to play that carbonated treacle during photo sessions.) If people find these things off-putting, that’s their problem, not a prejudice you must cater to. Being a wheelchair user is not germane to the task at hand.

Strictly for your own convenience, without regard to the delicate sensibilities of any aspiring model, you might choose to say something to avoid last-minute walkouts, but that is a practical consideration, not an ethical obligation.